Investigators can’t rule out foul play in case of missing Amish teen Linda Stoltzfoos
The family of Linda Stoltzfoos, an 18-year-old Amish teen from Lancaster County, Pennsylvania who went missing over a week ago after attending church, is asking the public for prayers as investigators say they can’t yet rule out foul play.
“Now that the primary and secondary search of the local area have been completed the primary way you can help Linda right now is through prayer. Pray that the Lord keeps her safe and that we are successful in finding her,” a statement from Stoltzfoos’ family posted on Facebook last Saturday reads.
“At this point there are a variety of agencies involved in continuing the search for her whereabouts. Search and rescue teams, detectives, the police department, and even the FBI. If you have first-hand knowledge or information that may be considered a lead, please inform the authorities immediately.”
According to East Lampeter Township Police, Stoltzfoos is about 5 feet, 10 inches tall and weighs about 125 pounds. She was last seen June 21 around 12:30 p.m. on a farm on Stumptown Road, near Bird-in-Hand, close to where the church service was held. She was wearing a tan dress, a white apron and a white cape.
After more than a week of prayer vigils and searches for the missing teen by security officials and volunteers from the community, there is still no sign of Stoltzfoos.
“Nothing leads us to believe that she wanted to leave on her own,” East Lampeter Township Police Lt. Matthew Hess told The York Daily Record. “We can’t rule out foul play or that she left on her free will.”
Local police are asking any drivers, bicyclists, pedestrians or others who may have traveled along certain roads on June 21 between 8 a.m. and 4 p.m. to contact them, WGAL reported Monday.
Those roads are Mill Creek School Road, Stumptown Road, Gibbons Road, Beechdale Road and Mill Creek Road.
“Some people may have noticed something, observed something while they were traveling on those roadways that they feel might be insignificant, or they did see something and just weren’t feeling comfortable contacting the police,” Hess told WGAL. “We are reaching out to them to ask them to contact us as part of the investigation. No tip is too small. No little bit of information is not worthy of at least letting us hear about it.”
While there is a history of young people leaving the Amish community in rebellion, investigators say this does not appear to be the case with Stoltzfoos. Some youngsters leave the Amish community due to the strict interpretation and application of Scripture in which the community separates itself from the things of the world.
Merv Fisher, Stoltzfoos’ uncle who left the order years ago, as did his wife, who is Stoltzfoos’ sister, told The York Daily Record on Sunday that no matter what happens with Stoltzfoos’ case, the Amish community will forgive just as they did with the Nickel Mines School tragedy.
On Oct. 2, 2006, 32-year-old Charles Carl Roberts IV entered West Nickel Mines Amish School in Lancaster County’s Bart Township where he killed five girls and injured five others before killing himself.
“The Amish are very quick to forgive. ‘It’s God’s will, and we forgive,’ is what they think. They know there are consequences, as far as the legal system goes. But here, they don’t know what happened. There are no consequences. But they have an unwavering faith that the truth will prevail. They have an unwavering faith that God is in control,” Fisher explained.
“But, here, they don’t know what the truth is yet. They don’t know what happened. Nobody knows what happened. It seems the entire community is searching for an answer, and we don’t have one yet. The darkness will be exposed and the truth will prevail. The community has hope. They know the truth will prevail.”
Hess said the case was “quite unusual” because he hasn’t encountered anything like it in the last 15 years.
“I don’t recall anything like this in the last 15 years. It’s like she just disappeared without any reason,” he told The York Daily Record.
Fisher noted however that the one positive thing he has seen from Stoltzfoos’ disappearance is how it has brought the community together.
“It’s more than I’ve seen in my 40 years,” he was quoted as saying. “It has brought the outside English and Mennonite and Amish communities together in a way I’ve never seen.”
The East Lampeter Township police confirmed to Fox43 that the FBI is now assisting in the search for Stoltzfoos.